面试题库

14 天 RAG：从检索到可信回答

D7 第一周综合：把六天的零件装成一个可一键启动的检索问答服务并复盘

• 你会怎么划分一个检索增强生成系统的模块边界？其中哪一层最应该做成可替换的，为什么？How would you draw the module boundaries of a RAG system, and which layer most needs to be swappable? Why?

  国内高频海外高频基础#architecture#modularity#embeddings

  分析过程 · 先想清楚再作答

  1. 这题考的是你有没有真的维护过这类系统。只按「解析、切块、检索、生成」复述一遍流程图，面试官会判定你只搭过 demo——流程图人人都会画，切口画在哪才是经验。
  2. 给一条可复用的判据再往下推：切口应该落在「将来最可能被整个换掉」的地方，而不是按代码量或者功能名称均分。
  3. 用它过一遍：embedding 一年会换好几次，换一次库里所有向量作废、必须全量重算，所以它必须是接口；存储可能从 PostgreSQL 换成专用向量库，而且摄取和查询都要通过它，所以它是两条链路的唯一交界；切块策略在调优期天天改，所以它必须是配置项而不是硬编码。
  4. 结论：最该做成可替换的是 embedding 那一层，理由不是「设计模式」，而是「换模型这件事真的会发生，且发生时代价极高」。
  5. 顺手点出抽象的代价：每多一层间接就多一次跳转和一份心智负担，所以判据是「那件事会不会真的发生」，不会发生的别抽象。
  6. 可预期的追问：那生成模型要不要也抽象？答案是要，但优先级低——换生成模型不需要重算任何存量数据，回滚也便宜，所以它是配置项而不是一层接口。

  How to reason about it · think before answering

  1. This question separates people who have maintained such a system from people who have only built a demo. Reciting the pipeline diagram is not an answer; where you cut it is.
  2. Offer a reusable criterion first: cut where a layer is most likely to be replaced wholesale, not by lines of code or by tidy functional names.
  3. Apply it. Embedding models change several times a year, and each change invalidates every stored vector, so that layer must be an interface. Storage may move from PostgreSQL to a dedicated vector database, and both ingestion and query talk through it, so it is the single shared boundary. Chunking changes daily during tuning, so it belongs in config, not in code.
  4. Conclusion: the embedding layer is the one that must be swappable, because the swap is both likely and expensive, not because interfaces are good style.
  5. Name the cost of abstraction too: every indirection is one more hop while debugging, so the test is whether the change will actually happen.
  6. Expected follow-up: should the generation model be abstracted as well? Yes, but at lower priority, because swapping it does not force recomputation of stored data and rollback is cheap. It is a config value, not a layer.

  答题要点

  • 先给判据：切口落在最可能被整体替换的那一层，不按代码量或功能名称均分。
  • embedding 是最该抽象的一层：换模型意味着存量向量全部作废、必须全量重算，代价高且真的会发生。
  • 存储层是摄取与查询唯一的交界，接口要先定下来再谈两边实现。
  • 切块与检索路数做成配置项，因为它们在调优期改动最频繁，改一次不该动代码。
  • 抽象有成本，判据是那件事会不会真的发生；不会发生的抽象就是过度设计。

  Key points

  • Lead with the criterion: cut where a layer is most likely to be replaced wholesale.
  • The embedding layer is the one to abstract: swapping models invalidates every stored vector and forces a full recompute.
  • Storage is the single boundary shared by ingestion and query, so define its interface before either implementation.
  • Chunking and retrieval routes belong in configuration because they change most often during tuning.
  • Abstraction costs indirection, so only abstract changes that will actually happen.